Two of this blog's followers, Mike and Wrestlepex, emailed me and identified Kenny Dykstra's opponent in the photo below as J.D. Michaels.
J.D. Michaels was wrestling for OVW at the time contributor Jim took these photos in 2008. If he looks somewhat familiar, it's because J.D. has been featured here on Beefcakes of Wrestling under his current ring name J.D. Maverick. Here's a mini-gallery of J.D. Maverick in all his beefcake glory.